The News

Metro UI - the elephant in the Windows 8 room

Last Updated on Monday, 25 June 2012 13:59 Published on Monday, 25 June 2012 13:59

Let me get this out of the way. I am a whore for the new. When Microsoft released its first previews of Windows 8 I rushed in and installed them. The Metro interface was different but innovative and I could immediately see the benefits of a similar interface across all my devices (given that my main phone uses Windows Phone 7). 

But then I sat a friend who's not a techie at my laptop and asked him to use Win 8. He was hopelessly lost. Not just lost, but he became confused and angry and increasingly agitated as he tried to work his way through Metro. He swore a lot and said he simply would not upgrade to Windows 8. No way. Windows 7 for life. Or Mac OS X, even. But not Metro.

 

I'd seen that behaviour before - when Ubuntu released the innovative Unity desktop (which saw Linux Mint almost immediately overtake Ubuntu on the DistroWatch charts), and more closer to home everytime I've redesigned a web publication or a magazine (i.e, I've had readers of redesigned publications call for my sacking and scream hysterically at me on the phone). Basically, people hate change, but they go ballistic when the change means they have to throw away the investment in learning an interface and have to start again, even if the new interface is enormously superior by almost all objective measures.

I think as geeks we're missing the elephant in the room of Windows 8: the likely vicious reaction from the unsuspecting public to Microsoft's re-invention of the OS interface. In reality, Windows users are about to be sent to re-education camp, courtesy of the massive changes in the wider computing ecosystems brought on by the arrival of mobile and tablets that have forced Microsoft to go down the Metro route. Put simply, with Windows 8, Microsoft has decided to kill the way we've traditionally interfaced with a PC and is asking everyone to learn what's effectively a new user interface.

Think I'm exaggerating? Get a non techie friend to try Windows 8 Release Preview for the first time and do familiar stuff with it. It will be a surprisingly unsettling experience for them and if we haven't yet seen a revolt from other users yet it's because early testers of preview versions tend to be geeks who can deal with change.

Metro replaces the familiar Windows desktop with the live tiles of the Windows Phone 7 smartphone OS: the Start button disappears, application windows take up the full screen and you switch screens by sliding your mouse to the side of the display. Yes, there's a Desktop tile that restores the familiar interface and makes you think you're back in Windows 7, but Windows effectively delegates the old desktop to an app, a kind of Windows 7 mode, while Metro lurks in every corner.

In short, Windows 8 brings the most radical change to a desktop interface we've seen and, worse, on a mainstream OS which is the global standard. We expect many traditional and perhaps older users simply won't make the transition. That' because the Metro UI has its roots in smartphones rather than PCs and will make far more sense to a generation for whom mobiles and tablets are as important, if not more so, than the PC. Windows 8 will be an OS that will challenge a generation of users. [apcmag]